2012-2013 season: 25-7 record (16-4 GPAC) No. 9 postseason national ranking
Head Coach: Drew Olson

2011-2012 season: 34-3 record (18-2 GPAC) Regular-season GPAC Champions, GPAC Tournament Champions, NAIA Division II Fab Four appearance, No. 3 postseason national ranking
Head Coach: Drew Olson

2010-2011 season: 15-17 record (6-12 GPAC)
Head Coach: Drew Olson

2009-2010 season: 21-11 record (11-7 GPAC) 
Head Coach: Drew Olson 

2008-2009 season: 28-9 record (14-4 GPAC) 3rd Place in GPAC Regular-season
Head Coach: Drew Olson 

2007-2008 season: 26-7 record (13-6 GPAC)
Head Coach: Drew Olson 

2006-2007 season: 19-13 record (10-8 GPAC)
Head Coach: Drew Olson 

2005-2006 season: 13-17 record (7-11 GPAC)
Head Coach: Todd Voss 

2004-2005 season: 31-5 record (15-3 GPAC) GPAC Tournament Champions, NAIA Division II Fab Four appearance
Head Coach: Todd Voss 

2003-2004 season: 28-8 record (14-4 GPAC)
Head Coach: Todd Voss 

2002-2003 season: 36-2 record (16-0 GPAC) Regular-season GPAC Champions, NAIA Division II Fab Four appearance
Head Coach: Todd Voss

2001-2002 season: 28-6 record (13-5 GPAC)
Head Coach: Micah Parker

2000-2001 season: 19-10 record (8-9 GPAC)
Head Coach: Micah Parker 

NAIA Fab Four

2012, 2005, 2003

NAIA Round of Eight

2009, 2008, 2004, 1997

NAIA Tournament Qualifier

2013, 2012, 2010, 2009, 2008, 2005, 2004, 2003, 2002, 1998, 1997, 1992

Other honors

7-time NAIA Academic Champion as awarded by WBCA